The Hunter's Children

очень хорошо, но сильно затянуто, местами хлопорты

Enjoyed song, nothing more.

Как уже сказали, это пересказ Клеймора с фоновой музыкой, при котором иногда совпадает синхронизация. Самое правильное имхо - это в куплете история , в припеве сражения. Тут же все намешано. Глобальное M/V ужасно, несмотря все эффекты и маски. Да и просто очень длинная песня с длинными частями. Считаю , что песня просто не подходит.
Просто посмотри высоко оцененные клипы по 1 аниме и попытайся понять, что не так в твоей работе.

We are surrounded of newfags in this section. They prefer to give themselves too much importance with the low scores without not even commenting. Kind of discouraging

Bebop0083 написал(а):
I've always done fairy well on other sites youtube

Everyone does well on youtube, even those naruto vidoes with 100 kb/s audio, spanish hardsubs, lipflap, frameblending and a cut every 15 seconds.

About your video:

It's a claymore recap with background music, nothing more. For me someone who hasn't seen claymore it's plain boring.

Theres not enough (barely any) action sync to make me interested in it as an action video.
The fx is plain and looks old, probably because the video is old itself. Most AMVs just don't age well.
Theres no visual concept or anything that sparks my interested at all, so why would I keep watching a 5 Minute recap for an Anime I know nothing about.

It's probably an okay watch for claymore fans but that's it.

I don't really care about scores, but I have to agree that the exam section is rating too harsh. Almost all videos that actually go to the frontpage increase in rating, but it isn't as much as you want it to be and it has nothing to do with popularity, everyone gets hated equally.

Bebop0083 написал(а):
If a popular editor made this video you would have eaten this video all up.

If a popular editor made this video they would have lost a big part of their popularity : )

Работа направлена на тех, кто в курсе? А то создается такое впечатление, что тем, кто не в теме Клейморов, тут просто нечего делать. Видеоряд настолько жестко порезан, что уловить историю сложно даже знающему, а каково тогда новичкам...
Или тут своя история? Если да, то какая именно? Её найти и прочитать еще сложнее. Песня сильная, но это и во вред работе. Она перебарщивает с атмосферой борьбы. И если честно, видео смотрится еле-еле уже ко второй минуте.

Eion написал(а):
You should work harder on improving instead of caring what people think! Popular editors are popular for a reason, they have proven them selves and they would not make something like this video. You should work on trying to get higher quality scenes and practice your scene selection alongside sync. Editing takes time, and i'm guessing you are fairly new. You have a long way to go.

I'm not exactly new just new to this site. I've always done fairy well on other sites youtube, and ive done alright even on amv.org. I've been around since early 2000-1'sh era editng. Hell I've even done well in some amv contests so I chose a lot of my best vids to put on here and they get treated like trash. I do put a lot of effort into my videos. I mainly do videos just for my self but it annoys the hell out of me when I go above and beyond for different style of editing on a video and it gets the same score that I would do on another video that is straight cut editing. That's my main gripe. Plus no one leaves constructive criticism which I am all for as long as its not harsh nitpicking. I just don't understand why people leave scores the way they do. This is the most harshest site that I've been too for amvs.
---------

Darth999 написал(а):

If you don't like the film it doesn't metter how much effects it contains. It's not like a test, just personal perception. But indeed, popular editor's works has some privilegies, it's not good. So here is my advice, stop trying to please auditory, try to please yourself. That's all.

That's my main goal when working on amvs. I do it mainly for my self. Its just depressing to see something you worked on really hard to get treated like trash. I guess haters will just be haters.

You should work harder on improving instead of caring what people think! Popular editors are popular for a reason, they have proven them selves and they would not make something like this video. You should work on trying to get higher quality scenes and practice your scene selection alongside sync. Editing takes time, and i'm guessing you are fairly new. You have a long way to go.

Bebop0083 написал(а):
Again you guys are being way too picky. I'm done trying to please you guys with a good video. I did videos with effects = low scores. I did videos without effects= low scores. I don't know what you guys want. I'm sick of people giving low scores for no reason. If a popular editor made this video you would have eaten this video all up. Well I'm done seeing my best works getting torn to shreds here.

If you don't like the film it doesn't metter how much effects it contains. It's not like a test, just personal perception. But indeed, popular editor's works has some privilegies, it's not good. So here is my advice, stop trying to please auditory, try to please yourself. That's all.

Again you guys are being way too picky. I'm done trying to please you guys with a good video. I did videos with effects = low scores. I did videos without effects= low scores. I don't know what you guys want. I'm sick of people giving low scores for no reason. If a popular editor made this video you would have eaten this video all up. Well I'm done seeing my best works getting torn to shreds here.