AMV News

[Snowcrash]

Ranking and comments of the judges (Neb and Rody) + DDL Links (on the banners) :


1st : Vidok

Effective at any points of view, whether in editing, synchro and technique (although it's still quite simple).
we can just regret that the storyline is a little too linear because it resumes exactly the film storyline.
Congratulations for your victory, Vidok!

2nd : Aya and KP

A mmv divided into 2 parts, where the first narration is excellent, the effects here are well thought out and allows provide a very dramatic photo-story.
The second part is a 360 degrees changement, where humor and parody are very present. A big applause for this little breath of fresh air.

3rd : bnj

Excellent, the atmosphere, the choice of scenes. We liked the illustrated theme .
We can think your clip is a random editing but in the end we see it as moments of life, seeing the world. We would like to say that it's shameful to put pretty girls out of the water to have favorable opinions of the judges. An excellent multi!

4th : 5zigen

It is clean, speed, it is unwavering. The editing is very dynamic and we move quickly in this death race.

5th : VinceRage

A clip well managed, technically difficult to blame something even if sometimes few effects are useless.
The editing is divided into 2 parts : one calm enough to be pleasant and another that is more rhythmic especially because of the musical selection. A good storyline which is well-represented by the pictures.

6th : The35YOK

The idea is very good. Here we forget the sync in favour of the image.
It's still a particular clip because of the subject and the bias.
The clip looks like a TV report which seems very professional (the kind of clip that you could discover on FRANCE 5).
Good integration of securities for the final scene.

7th : Frayge

It is clean, the music is well chosen. Some subtleties in the choice of scenes compared to the sound.
We took a flight into these machines! Embark on a nice flight.

8th : KP

It is an original idea, even if it decreases during the viewing.
It should be noted a nice melange of different worlds and the search for similarities.
Some subtleties well thought, waking of Robocop and we see Darth Vader... LOL
The duration of the clip is quite important, the effect of surprise at the beginning of viewing decreases unfortunately panting gradually as we approach the end.

9th : Laharl

The storyline is nice, we follows with pleasure the misadventures of Bean.
Some subtleties well thought to mark the synchro.
The music is nice.
We blame that THE rotoscopy which is not be well made : the viewer goes out of the atmosphere.

10th : Atvaark

A mmv built on the atmosphere : here we stop to laugh.
It is dark and we feel that the drama is described through flashbacks.
The few remains of ouclippo (change in red) here are smart and they reinforce the disturbing side of the subject.

11th : Hard_Gilou

Excellent, laugh out loud, it's so daft! Gilou is so scary.
Very original with a desire to stand out. Note that the editing corresponds well to the music.
The choice of music is quite "special" and repetitive.
You will love or hate its originality.

12th : Niwa

We see a video-clip of a fan here! ^ ^
There is a real desire to introduce the series and its universe through a specific tragedy of this saga.
It is nice, but it is not always clean.
However, most of the work is in editing and it is really correct!
On the road to the door of stars ...

13th : bax390

Excellent start, cars ... speed, girls etc...
The universe of tunning is offered us through to this nice editing.
However, the "multi screen" and "private jokes" get out us of the video-clip.
A little more control in editing and your video-clip will be great !
Vrommmmmmmm!

14th : Sword Dancer

A nice music, a nice choice of scenes.
However, a lot of errors and bad resolutions, transitions are clumsy and bad controlled and even though they are well thought out (such as the eagle and the effect at 1.07 and the sapphire effect 1.40 - even if we understand the attempt with the leaves). The use of "neat video" plugin reduces the quality of the video.
It is still very enjoyable to watch even though it is far to be perfect.

15th : Kazend

A HOME-MADE of the most original ever! 100% free GMO!
Nothing but the title is worth the trip.
Bravo pour la réalisation (storyboard etc ...).
However, the quality of the video is to review.

16th : Snowsheep

It is far TGS video-clip here!
One feels that the clip does not reflect your experience and the requirement of your previous clips.
We've even laughed at times.
The effects are really very "noobs".

17th : Ced

We see a video-clip of a fan here too! ^ ^
The choice of music and the series are well thought out.
Some judicious choice of scenes.
You have a sense of the editing, but the flash effects are old school, and some technical problems taint the work. It remains very imperfect.


Out of competition: too much text Mr. Jones

The editing is non-existent because the clip about this lies in the subject.
It remains exciting to follow, one finds a job through a passion.
Well done Dr. Jones!


It will have soon a pool on AMV-france forum to choose the public prize.

[VIDOK]

Не ожидал, что выйграю ) Спасибо организаторам за интересный конкурс!

[Костоправ]

VIDOK
Молодец, уделал французов)

[Bjakua]

VIDOK
Поздравляю)

[internity]

Так держать

[Nexus]

Такими темпами мы забугорных друзей быстро уделаем, первые шаги уже сделаны и ВЦА не за горами)
VIDOK, Лучший) Продолжай в том же духе)
PS
I`m very grateful to organizers for a good competition, and as consequence set of interesting and beautiful clips

[redbull]

[Nexus]

[Snowcrash]

If the three russians contestants of the Real Contest want, they can present their video-clip on this page of AMV-france forum:
http://forum.amv-france.com/autres-creations-f35/

We will post comments in english.

VinceRage has already posted his video.


Personnaly, I like a lot the video of bnj (it is his second clip, like Vidok ?) because it looks like at In Motion by Toster (great video).

[Rody]

Congratulations Vidok. and thanks at Vincerage and 5zigen for your involvement. Your vid's is very good.

[Snowcrash]

Pool's results :

http://forum.amv-france.com/concours-f28/public-prize-who-is-the-winner-for-you-t827.html

But the pool is not yet over.