Soma

Очень понравилось, 5

Eazy написал(а):
So why did you make it a crossover? You just replaced Rize with Yuuko, but you literally stuck with the tokyo ghoul story. So even if you'd just use tokyo ghoul as source the video would be exactly the same.

i wont go in much details, but a big part of the Soma's story differs greatly from tokyo ghoul's story. And that's the reason he made it a crossover.

Ну в целом смотрится неплохо. Еще бы подтянуть бы монтажку (порой камера не плавная, а слишком резкая + временами очень статично и, как тут уже отметили, некоторые маски кривые), был бы вин. За все труды и идею поставлю 4, автору желаю подтянуть все то, про что я написал и будет гуд.

wow
it's been quite a while since i saw an improvement from ur works dion :o
that's indeed a good lvl up :)
& digi danna , nvm these savages who think that freedom means that u can do anything , haha & ya , looking forward to see ur entry too :33

What's a comment section without some spicy stuff? xDDDD
To all people: thnx for the comments i appreciate pointing out my weak spots. even though i started the project 3 months ago i had exams session in the middle blablabla it was a rally with time for real. Google translate my secret friend sucks big time and keeps making trouble for me though.

Не влюбляйся во всяких там, а то без глазика останешься, а то и ещё чего поважнее. Мораль которую Я смог извлечь из данного амв.
В общем-то неплохо, местами симпатично так смотрелось, под приятную музычку, добротная работка, но, всё таки, так и не выпрыгнувшая из категории "ничего особенного".

Fury написал(а):

Lmao usless for me? This amv aint even made by u and none were talking to u until u got into. So chill the fuck down, JFC another one thinking he rule everything, burn whatever u wish mate, performence>words.

Do u even know me to reply to me in the 1st place ?? , if no then shine aru
Grow up a little aho detaku

DiGiCyber011 написал(а):
daremokirishinai aru
do not use teh " comment section is free for all " as an argument to defend on yer pal
i'll make myself extremely clear to settle this once & for all fury
" if yer comment won't help then u're useless to me "
besides " u touch my anili , i would burn yer soul "
got it ??

Lmao usless for me? This amv aint even made by u and none were talking to u until u got into. So chill the fuck down, JFC another one thinking he rule everything, burn whatever u wish mate, performence>words.

L33tamv написал(а):


stop drinking and get on the internet its not good for your health kek

did anyone told ya that that's not even funny ??

DiGiCyber011 написал(а):
DiGiCyber011

stop drinking and get on the internet its not good for your health kek

daremokirishinai aru
do not use teh " comment section is free for all " as an argument to defend on yer pal
i'll make myself extremely clear to settle this once & for all fury
" if yer comment won't help then u're useless to me "
besides " u touch my anili , i would burn yer soul "
got it ??

To DiGiCyber011:
Comment section is free for all, everyone is free to say and answer on their own will and freedom, aint just for criticism and aint no rule around that says comments should be made only if they imply criticism. Nor to mention here is internet where the only criticism related to our hobby called editing are made only by ppl who know what they talk about, proved by self performence or knowledge (get Thai Lopezed). Also just bcuz is a 5 mins or 10 mins crossover it doesnt mean is good or that the hard work the editor puts in will be 100% pleasent for all or if is under the idea of "is a hard work = good", it is noticeble the hard working but just bcuz u took the risk to cross a 4 mins amv that doesnt mean nothing if aint done properly.

To Lucifer:
I liked it, not a big fun of video frames nor the plot, if the story could be different w.o those ghoul stuffs i think it could be a bigger win for urself. Some manipulation were rlly good,a big lvl up for urself. Wish u gl and all the best.

L33tamv написал(а):
is my fan kappa123

shine aru
u ever knew how hard is it to make a 4 min crossover , don't u ever dare to this guy by " yer fan " just cuz u made a familiar MEP part the same resources
learn how to give real criticism or keep yer mouth shut the next time
cuz if y'think that u're a cool guy then i have to tell ya that u're embarrassing yerself that way
& ya , try to be more polite the next time to other contestants , & don't speak as if u're one of them -_-

В конце чуть чуть потерял идею, но вообще мне очень понравилась! Thank you LuciferAMV

Что-то меня эти кроссоверы не вставляют. Нет той атмосферности, которую хотелось бы видеть.

Nice LA but weak track. 5, and good luck for next time

Саунд подобран слабенький , весь клип чего-то ждёшь , а какой-то развязки нет , и всё из-за трека. Кстати, почему пластырь на глазу хаотично появлялся и исчезал - не вкурил. К чему круто сделанные сцены на кинопленке - тоже. В плане эффорта почти всё сильно и стильно. Но ненужно. После просмотра как-то ничего и не осело, увы.

a level up indeed gotta agree , i can see you going only forward after this i guess you already know your mistakes its a pity you didnt have much time keep going

The idea seemed for me decent, as there are enough atmospheric scenes in both sources and they are interesting in connecting. Actually I didn’t like compositing (because even 2d scenes should bring the idea of physics, such as lighter-darker elements of the composition, proper DOF, etc), tapes from “City” where it was used not as transition (it was too aggressive as background and didn’t give a chance to concentrate on the characters). Sync was rather accurate, but in the slower track parts vocals were a bit ignored, and this ruined atmosphere. For such vocals the movements in the scenes were too complete, and this affected the flow a little, imo.
Good luck

fotsh написал(а):
Centurione... come back please

эххх

Was a ''level up'' indeed
Good luck in the rankings

L33tamv написал(а):
Lucifer is my fan kappa123

Well, you could say that he indeed enjoys himself some autism now and then. keepo456

Lucifer is my fan kappa123

Хорошая идея,.Некоторые моменты смотрелись довольно стильно.Если бы не кривые масочки,топчик бы был (

EVOsvik написал(а):
Ээм а для чего было женского персонажа менять...вроди бы это было не обязательно..

новенький тут? :D

Centurione... come back please


p.s 7.5/10

для меня везде, где фигурирует Centurione, оценка будет 5.
ибо после той пандоры....)))))))

Да что такое с композом у новайсов в этом году.
---------
Не стоило такие маски показывать в скриншотах. Особенно это касается последнего скриншота.

Have you done any mask color correction? Most of them are too notable.

4 for plot and sense transition. Really liked it, but masks aren't that good

EVOsvik написал(а):
Ээм а для чего было женского персонажа менять...вроди бы это было не обязательно..

Кадров с бабой из гуля очень немного, думаю поэтому

So why did you make it a crossover? You just replaced Rize with Yuuko, but you literally stuck with the tokyo ghoul story. So even if you'd just use tokyo ghoul as source the video would be exactly the same.

this i like 10/10 would bang u must win