“It is natural to man to indulge in the illusions of hope. We are apt to shut our eyes against a painful truth, and listen to the song of that siren till she transforms us into beasts.
……
It is in vain, sir,to extenuate the matter. Gentlemen may cry, Peace, Peace-- but there is no peace.There is no retreat but in submission and slavery!Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!”
Информация
Аниме: Ghost In The Shell, The Animatrix, Ergo proxy, GENIUS PARTY, KARAS, Mind Game, BLAME!, Tekkonkinkreet, 日本アニメ（ーター）見本市
Музыка: 2WEI - Survivor, Minako Obata - The World of Midnight
? !
Это на самом деле так?
Я никогда не думал об этом, эта причина действительно ... невообразимы ...
- Вообще-то ютуб к черным полосам ни при чём. Отказ от черных полос пошел ещо с тех времён когда Интернет был нет как быстр и доступен (ютуба не было вообще), а качать видео с черными полосами которые занимают не полезное место в ролике и добавляют лишний вес файла - расточительность.
Risen404,
Я не вижу изображение, которое вы отправили. Я не могу открыть URL. Если я хочу открыть его, мне нужно «через стену», но в последние годы это становится все более и более опасным.
Но я могу понять, что вы имеете в виду (если с Google Translate все в порядке), я должен заявить, что черная граница этой работы предназначена для максимального отображения информации и последнего специального эффекта, потому что если они заставляют людей чувствовать, что они не содержат никакой информации Так раздражает ... (я никогда не слышал об этой проблеме в Китае), тогда мне жаль
---------
MrNosec,
If so, wouldn't the longest of them be cut off?
Regarding the ratio ... For example, the material downloaded from the "nyaa" website is actually a ratio of 1980 * 1080, and then there will be a black border inside ... Or in the international, how do amv authors download animations?
---------
okhostok,
Thank you for your serious evaluation.
00: 14-00: 17 That was the last lens made in this work, because I do n’t have a better lens to put there. In the end, I can only choose a lens that ’s not that bad, because I do n’t have much time. . (As a result, the deadline for the competition was postponed within a few days)
00: 22-00: 29 Actually this shot is for the "eye-opening" shot after 00:29. What I want to express is that this person is beginning to notice the strangeness of the world. (More and more rapid and abnormal crowd activities, and finally become digital, then black screen, and then open eyes)
00: 37-00: 40 I have done a lot of color adjustments here, and at the end I started to wonder if I was overdone, but it still seems that I have not adjusted it well.
00:42 roughly means "waking up is painful, please let me sleep"
00: 59-01: 19 The original design of this paragraph was that those who were outside the matrix struggled with the matrix, and some contestants once again sneaked into the matrix to wake up more people. But when editing, I found that there was not so much time to display (the last two characters can still see the traces of this design)
1.15-1.28 The design of these two paragraphs is that the monitor has already observed the point of preparing to control them. The reason they run away is because they have discovered the truth (they live in a matrix) and they are being stared at by people in black who seem strange.
2.09-2.46 These two paragraphs are basically the concept of escape is getting more and more intense. As for why they ran away before, why they ran away is related to their original animation settings. In the matrix, as long as the limit is exceeded, the system will be abnormal. Although the original works of these works are not all the Matrix World view, but all can be explained together in this way. (But I feel that this relationship is not intense enough)
2.46-3.08 They were caught. Then he chose to commit suicide by suicide and was caught by grabbing, in which the athlete actually ran out of the matrix, he was pulled back into the matrix by special means (this can be seen in the original)
The writing of this story is mainly based on the setting of "Matrix Animation Edition", and also puts several other worldview characters in it (if you have seen their stories, I think you will know that I think Why should they be there). But it is true that it is not easy to understand him. I failed to express him too clearly. There are a lot of settings in my heart and I ca n’t show it very well (this is why I translated a lot of plot explanations. The reason in the comments).
The competition logo ... Well ... this is the last one to add, even the entire ending song was edited because I couldn't think of a good place to put it ...
As for the black border issue, I have made many explanations in the comments. In fact, with regard to the 1-2 frames, it appears that so few of them are also a design of mine, in order to show a kind of "accidental" or "real" arrival. I really thought about it a lot, but it seems that I still do n’t recognize your level of resentment
Это естественно, любой пересвет, сильный контраст, всё что создаёт препятствия получению информации с картинки - мешает, ну и конечно играет роль потертости этой фишки годами массового использования в ютубчике.
https://i.imgur.com/nldjWTM.png
- Ghost in the Shell= 1920x1036
- Tekkonkinkreet= 1920x816
- The Animatrix= 1920x810
If you only used these 3 anime, what resolution must your video be taking in consideration you DON'T want to scale any of the anime? It would have to be at least 1920x810, the widest resolution of them all. There's no need to add any black bars during editing, set the project itself to the resolution you want from the start and edit it like that.
Я вижу До этого я действительно не думал об удалении черной границы исходного материала путем изменения масштаба видео.
Но насчет «все они имеют одинаковое соотношение» на самом деле не соответствует действительности. По сути, каждая анимация имеет различное соотношение черных границ, и две из них не имеют черных границ. Теперь причина, по которой соотношение выглядит одинаково, заключается в том, что я установил его отдельно. С черной рамкой он использует черную рамку самого большого «Matrix Animation Edition» в качестве пропорции.
Сначала я думал, что причина ненависти к черным границам заключается в том, что они теряют информацию, но это, похоже, отличается от того, что я думал. Я уменьшил потери изображения унифицированным способом и использовал специальный эффект, чтобы придать черной рамке ее значение, но, похоже, это не дает хорошего эффекта
Yes, to be honest. Why? Because it is nearly unnoticeable, you just used it in 1-2 scenes. You could have played with black borders more creatively (like smoothly increasing or decreasing in some scenes).
Okay, finally you made me watch the video thoroughly.
From:
00:00 - 00:14 - good atmosphere, everything is static, everything is in place.
00:14 - 00:17 - weird movement like noise that ruins your static atmosphere that you have created before.
00:17 - 00:19 - everything is static, everything is in place.
00:19 - 00:22 - everyone until now were doing some daily activities, but this person is not doing it.
00:22 - 00:29 - too dynamic scenes for this part of the music and too bright for dark atmosphere (and ugly).
00:29 - 00:37 - good.
00:37 - 00:40 - very contrasted two scenes: a very old person in black/white = bright person in colors.
00:42 - I did not understand the text.
00:44 - 00:59 - ok.
00:59 - 1:09 - the chosen scenes do not fit to the music's "explosiveness"
1:09 - 1:15 - ok.
1:15 - 1:19 - so flat and ugly characters, that makes the viewer a bit confused. Feels out of place.
1:19 - 1:28 - It is hard to interpret what scenes are meaning.
1:28 - 1:34 - running, ok.
1:34 - 1:54 - shows history, ok.
1:54 - 2:00 - false hopes, despair, good.
2:00 - 2:09 - ok.
2:09 - 2:29 - Sports? Why?
2:29 - 2:46 - Creatures are fleeing, did not understand from what?
2:46 - 3:08 - Suicide, self-destruct, dying, ok.
Overall, a viewer can feel some story and atmosphere in this clip, but it is just very contrasting and not understandable. I did not like it.
In titles, Big Contest logo is very disturbing. You could have placed just text...
When I downloaded the source files, they were already like this. My addition of the black border was unified according to the range of "The Matrix". As for the display problem ... It seems to us that even with ultra-wide screens (or movie theaters), they still have black borders ... Maybe it is really difficult to understand each other at this point.
I did add an extra black border, which is about 1 pixel more than the "Matrix" animated version. For uniformity, they (other animations with black borders) have different original black borders.
Your video (without the black bars) is 1920x800 (aspect ratio of 2.40:1), when you fullscreen a video of that aspect ratio on a 16:9 monitor (1920x1080 for example) it automatically has black bars at the top and bottom because the vertical size of the video is smaller than your screen, example: https://i.imgur.com/P9Jlw15.mp4
Also if you watch it on a ultra widescreen monitor, it won't have black bars at all, because it fits the extra wide screen perfectly, most movies are either in 2.35:1 or 1.85:1 aspect ratio (yes even in China) and all of them form black bars if watched on a 16:9 monitor (when fullscreen).
People don't hate black bars (or they shouldn't), what people don't like is 16:9 videos with black bars added on them, it's useless rendered pixels making file size needlessly larger and when compressed on streaming websites the black bars can even start to blend with the scenes themselves. If you want your video to have black bars when viewed, render them in the proper aspect ratio and don't add the bars by masking a black solid or by any other means, list of common resolutions/popular aspect ratios for each: https://blog.chameleondg.com/post/111891072017/resolution-aspect-ratio-cheat-sheet
1. Они не несут в себе никакой информации(исключение караоке-клип в которых на месте черной полосы может быть текст).
2. Видео без черных полос занимает всё пространство видеоплеера и легко растягивается под любой экран. (Тогда как с черными полосами вмонтированными в видео уже ничего не поделаешь как и с хардсабом (пример)).
3. Черные полосы можно обыгрывать, например динамично сужать или расширить (такое во многих клипах есть).
P.S: в вашем клипе черные полосы находятся на одном уровне. В такой ситуации их нужно было просто кадрировать (будет не стандартное соотношение сторон).
Может быть, машинный перевод попросил вас ответить на мои вопросы, и мои ответы для вас не заставили обе стороны понять, что это значит ...
This is the fault of Google Translate. All I want to say is "black border".
Generally speaking, I understand this meaning. I understand that the "black border" itself does not contain the excess caused by meaning, but I did not think of a good way to solve this problem. (In China, changing the video output ratio is rare, basically all videos are 16: 9) As I said, the original material itself has a "black border", and changing the ratio is not my consideration Within (even if I know it now, I feel that doing so will lose the original picture without black border animation), so I want to use the last white pigeon feather to give meaning to it ... but is it still bad?
It is a bit complex to understand...
What do you mean by "black spots" and "black field", if I assume they are "black borders", then why do you hate them if you used them in this clip?
"Black Borders" are just unnecessary, so they should be removed. They do not represent any information or add anything emotional. They just prevent your video to be maximized.
Large Subtitles make people read that piece of text; we came here to watch the video, not to read. If you become more and more experienced, you will begin transmitting your thoughts without the help of a text.
one of the reasons to do it is to avoid having this
https://i.imgur.com/181EnpT.jpg
ur vid looks like its inside a black box instead of taking up the whole screen. I'm just nitpicking doe, this shit is everywhere.
The font is bruh, doesn't sit well at all with the background. The ANIME, MUSIC on top of letterboxing looks bad, imo
Вы не получили предыдущий ответ?
Okay, I got a rough idea.
But if you do this, wouldn't there be a part of the material that has no black field after such a ratio? How is this different from adding black spots to a picture without black spots?
I originally thought that the reason why I hate black spots here is because this is an obvious trick to please, but it seems that I misunderstood?
So why do you hate black scenes (and large subtitles)?
I do not quite understand you. Is there a video link to show the effect of this method you said? (Preferably on AMVNEWS)
instead of doing feather tricks you could've rendered the video in "ultrawide" to get "natural" letterboxing. Niggis on phones and ultrawide screens will love you
В анимации, которую я использую, только небольшая часть исходного материала не имеет черных пятен (вы можете проверить их сами). Если я хочу сознательно устранить черное пятно, то мне нужно увеличить большую часть изображения более чем на 30%, что очень плохо.
Я знаю, что на AMVNEWS людям, похоже, не нравятся черные пятна (хотя я не совсем понимаю, почему), но я не бессмысленно использую посредственный трюк. На самом деле, в конце видео вы можете увидеть черные смысл.(Голубиное перо, выпавшее из «настоящего» за черное поле)
https://i.imgur.com/eAvnJZC.jpg
Может быть, я неправильно понимаю значение слова «драма» в AMV
---------
Эль-тян,
Извините, это уже неудобно?
Я понял, что моё редактирование может быть недостаточно ясным, поэтому я подготовил больше скриншотов, чтобы объяснить и направить эту историю.
Но мне также интересно, если эти дополнительные скриншоты заставят людей чувствовать себя немного многословно. Если он действительно дает вам это чувство, я извиняюсь.
(В начале я даже подготовил 30 скриншотов)